My dear friend who describes herself as a ‘reluctant mother of two’, recently asked if Campbell and I were planning on having any more children. I answered truthfully - I was not sure. She looked at me gravely and said that ‘having one child is like travelling through life as a couple - only with an added bonus. Having two children is like running a crèche with your ex’.
She was of course joking, but it did raise a salient point – are we going to have any more children?
Since Leo was born, Campbell and I have been asked daily when we will be having another. It is a bizarre thing to ask brand new parents who are already try to cope with the enormity of having one child, let alone two.
A couple of months ago, Time Magazine had a fascinating article about only children. It explained that the image of The Only Child as the selfish, spoiled, demanding brat was defined by an early psychological researcher named Granville Stanley Hall. He had conducted study in 1895 ‘Of Perculiar and Exceptional Children’ where he concluded that ‘being an only child is a disease in itself’. Of course this extreme opinion has since been hugely discredited, but the seed is sown in our society that only children are somewhat misfits.
I am vehemently against this view. This is because (of course) I am an only child. I don’t consider myself unusual in the least and truly believe I do not appear like an only child. I have never felt that I am particularly spoilt, and equate my demand for attention with having been an actress, rather than my lack of siblings. I had a great childhood. I was very happy, had many friends and felt completely secure. And being the only one allowed me to be the sole focus of my parents economically. I was able to go to a good school, travel extensively with my mother and father and never wanted for a thing.
But did I miss out in other ways? My husband is technically an only child, but is also one of nine. He has eight half-siblings, but considers them full brothers and sisters and cares for them all deeply. He see them often and they are firmly ingrained in our lives. There are the inevitable arguments between them, but primarily there is a huge unconditional love and trust. They are a large sprawling family who adore each other, like only siblings can.
I have absolutely no understanding of this (though it must be said they have all gone out of their way to bring me into the fold as the British sister they never had).
Only children are on the rise. Economics are partly to blame. China’s One Child Policy has meant that the word ‘cousin’ no longer appears to exist. Do I want Leo to grow up having the best of everything material yet missing something familial?
I really cannot decide.
But then I don’t have to right now either. He is only 4 months old and I still have a few more years in me yet. Until we make a decision we have the next best thing – in three weeks time, we are moving next door to my husband’s sister and her family. Leo will be able to see his beloved cousin Ruby everyday -he may not have a sibling yet, but she will make a pretty wonderful substitute.
You are a treasure, Lisa.
ReplyDeleteThank you,
Granno
Dear Lisa. I think that childern ajust to whatever situation they are brought up in. I am 1 of 4 and while I enjoyed my siblings company most of the time I longed for the solitude of my own room instead of sharing with 3. I myself had just 2, Ben and Courtney. While again they enjoyed each others company while they were young they were able to be an only child in some aspects. There is 4 years between them so Ben was an only child for 4 years Courtney was an only child while Ben was at school. What ever you and DC decide to do in the future, with such a large extended family Leo, to, can have the best of both worlds.
ReplyDeleteMy Tuppence Worth
Jeanette
Lisa, I also struggled with the very same issue. After the birth of my first child Lillian nearly 4 years ago I decided that I didn't want anymore children. I worried how we'd struggle financially and I worried how I'd struggle emotionally. My hubby however really had his heart set on 2 children and by the time Lillian was 2 I started to worry that she would have a lonely childhood and never know what it was like to be an Aunt. I was also worried that my hubby may resent me over time. So to cut a long story short baby Jacob was born 5 months ago and even though for the moment at least we are struggling financially and life is so fast paced that some days I can barely catch my breath I couldn't be happier on my choice to go through it all again. Do what your heart tells you Lisa and as you said you still have a long time to go before you need to decide.
ReplyDeleteAll the best :)
Ah Chesney, Chesney, Chesney... Where did you, your blonde locks and your mole disappear to? That'll be Butlins.
ReplyDeleteHey Lisa
Loving the blog so far. Surely, you've bagged yourself some free formula? If not, get onto SMA and get yourself some advertising revenue! It's the least you deserve.
As a fellow 'only child', I also was very lucky to have had a happy and privileged childhood. I certainly didn't feel as if I was missing out at the time, quite the contrary, I was the sole focus of my parents love and attention, brilliant! I think it's only as I've got older that I wish I have a brother or sister. But having inherited one of each, plus three nieces (all under 4) is a handful, but a treasure.
Isn't is funny that being an 'only child' carries a stigma? And somehow we (I use the word we, but may mean I) feel the need to defend our position and reassure people that we're not all 'spoilt brats'! 'I hope I don't act like an only child'. Though I guess we're not alone. I heard someone use the phrase 'oh that's classic middle child behaviour', whatever that means. So someone will always come up with a label to justify/excuse/identify the behaviour for whatever position you have within a family unit.
Throw a curve ball in there, and test road 'We're not going to have children', and see what kind of reaction you get. You completely freak people out. An interesting discussion but I'm digressing.
So more than one? No doubt you'll take this decision in your stride. Can't offer up any advice on this one, best ask our Lizzy for the multiple perspective! But there's no doubt you'll make a fab mum to one, two, three, four, five, six...
Good luck with the move. G x
I find this subject very interesting indeed. I am a fellow only child and had a fantastic childhood and don't feel I am spoilt brat! However I had great friends and 2 cousins close in age that I grew up with and so never felt lonely.
ReplyDeleteIt is only since I have got older and seen my husband with his sibings that I have wondered what it would be like to have that unique love that people have for brothers or sisters. However families are so complicated that there is a chance you could have 3 children who can't stand each other and never speak!
After my first child I did not want anymore, my thinking was, why do you change something that is working really well as it is! After nearly 5 years I came to realise (with persuasion from hubby) that i would like another and have not looked back.
Infact after having my second I could have had loads more but as I have one of each who are both healthy and fab I think I will leave it there.
As long as you are happy with your decision it is the right one.
It is really a decision that only you and David can make.
ReplyDeleteEveryone has an opinion on the topic (whether they are qualified or not)but everyone's circumstances are different. I don't think there is the stigma of being an only child as much these days...I have friends who made the decision to have just one child and no one really questions it.
You may wake up one morning....when Leo is older and your life is easier as he is able to do more for himself and decide that you want another child (this happened to me) or you may decide that having one child is enough. Or the decision may be taken away from you when you find out you are pregnant despite all the precautions you have taken. (LOL!! Sorry but that has happened to a number of my friends.)
Enjoy every moment you have with Leo....he will grow up too quickly!!
Hi Lisa
ReplyDeletethis is only the second blog I have read of yours and can I say thank you for writing such things..as a mother of an only child I agree wholeheartedly with the decision that it's up to the parents.
I also do not consider my child (who is 23 by the way)to be anything remotely like the Time magazine article at all..I get kinda annoyed when the so called "experts" speak about such things and write "facts" that unless they are only child themselves really should not make such remarks.. I come from a large family I have 4 brothers and 1 sister so I also know what its like and yes I did at a point worry has he missed out on such things..however his cousin is only a year apart and they grew up together also so were like brother/sister relationship instead of cousins.
Anyways just wanted to let you know my opinion and again THANK YOU for your story
Teresa Schultz