Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Weaning Power of Lisa


I am Lisa Campbell and I bottle-feed my son.

It feels like an admission of guilt, but it is true.

Dr Jennifer James of RMIT University believes that formula is too readily available and should only be obtained via prescription.   

"The majority of women and new dads that you speak to will give you some reasons why it's important to breastfeed but there's still this pervasive belief that 'I'll try it and if I can't do it, formula's just as good', she is quoted as saying in today’s Courier Mail.

I tried. 

I couldn’t do it. 

So what would she suggest that I feed my son?

I bottle-feed my baby.  Don’t get me wrong, I was made totally aware of the huge benefits that he would receive from breast milk.  I was given countless pamphlets, schedules for classes and numbers for helplines.  But no information prevented me from getting a very aggressive case of mastitis and a recurring breast abscess that had to be surgically removed twice.  My son spent his third week on this earth, in hospital with me hooked up to an intravenous drip of antibiotics, trying to express milk whilst ensuring that I did not rip the ravaged skin of my breasts in the process.  I could not express enough to satiate my son, but could not put him to the breast because of the dressings and scars. 

I did not take the decision to bottle-feed lightly.  We all want our children to have the best start in life, but I discussed the options with my husband, obstetrician and surgeon and I truly believe that I made the right decision.

I have not spoken to many people about this, as I have been embarrassed by the grotesqueness of my problems.  But breastfeeding is a difficult and highly sensitive business and should be treated as such. 

Giving birth to your first child is hugely overwhelming.  Not only do you have the realization that this vulnerable being is totally dependent on you, you are dealing with the trauma that your body has gone through to bring this person into the world, hormonal changes and lack of sleep.  Then you are faced with a helpless little soul whose hunger your body cannot satisfy. 

There is only so long you can watch that child cry without turning to another source.

If you try breastfeeding and cannot do it – formula is the ONLY option, Dr James.  Gone are the days of the wet nurse and there is only one Salma Hayek to go around.  We as a society should be supporting women who cannot breastfeed, not castigating them or making their difficult plight harder.

Cans of formula carry a printed health warning on them.  Like cigarettes.  However, unlike cigarettes, formula is not damaging.  It may not be ideal but it is the best that some of us can offer our children.  We should not be made to feel like bad mothers because of our physical limitations.  

27 comments:

  1. Well said Lisa. I think it takes a lot of courage to write this for all to read. I think this sort of blog should be read by all expectant mum's, even mum's breastfeeding and all that have gone through this before. I was lucky enough to breastfeed for 13 months, but I've been living with me head in the clouds, I never realised how severe mastitis could be. I had it a few times, but nothing more then a few days of flu like symptoms. I also didn't realise the pressure put on mum's who tried and can't breastfeed. You know Leo is very loved and you have nothing to feel guilty for.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Lisa, Good on you. Great article. I also had trouble breast-feeding Nicky. I tried for 3 whole weeks. I also developed mastitis and was very emotional and in alot of pain with a 3 week old crying baby next to me. Thank goodness for my wonderful husband who took the baby and started bottle-feeding her needless to say happy mother and happy baby, but I still had the guilt and the failure inside. Nicky is now 20 and she has turned out beautiful and intelligent even though she was bottle-fed with formula

    ReplyDelete
  3. Love the article Lisa, I have bottle fed all three of my son's from birth. I made a choice for me and my children, they are happy and healthy little boys and to be completely honest you can not tell that they are different to breast fed children.
    The were still loved, nurtured and bonded with in the exact same way as a breast fed baby.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I bottlefed my son, Leo, as well and sometimes cried while doing it out of pure guilt. But guess what? He was on solids at 6 months and cows milk at 12 months just like every other baby and now he's nearly 2 and happy, healthy, social and an absolute sweetheart of a human being. Let's all give each other a break. Babies need love above all else. Does it matter what we feed them? Really? Great blog Lisa. X

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Lisa, Firstly I'm so sorry that you had such a hard time of it. I have never felt more haywire than the first few weeks of my baby's life and I hate to imagine what mastitis would have done to me. Although i was able to breastfeed for a few months, i also supplemented from day 3. It's such a shame that, even though i have a healthy, happy 6 month old baby, i still feel a sting of failure when i see another mum breastfeeding. I struggle with the mixed messages of "you're the mum, you know what's best" and not just "breast is best" but "breast should be the only option". The damage done to new mums' confidence is staggering. Only recently have i had the confidence to say, if you just love them, everything else will be ok.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good on you Lisa and well said. I breast fed both of my boys but (now) 4 year old Jake and I had a hard time in the first few weeks. I persevered and he was fed a combination of breast and bottle...didn't make a heck of difference to his outcome I reckon. Ali is just over 2 and still breastfeeds at least once a day (shock! horror! i'm sure)..but you know what? I don't care what the Knockers (*ahem*) out there have to say. It's between me and mine and you and yours and as long as they're loved and fed - MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS I say!
    PS: I hope you keep the blogging up - you're a good read!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Lisa, like many women hearing about this topic today has been very upsetting for me. Thank you for writing your blog and for being so honest with us. I'm truly sorry to hear that you had so many issues breastfeeding, but you have done the right thing by putting Leo onto a bottle. At the end of the day it doesn't matter where the food has come from just as long as they get it. A happy mother = a happy baby :)
    I also had problems breastfeeding. After the birth of my 3.5 year due to a very traumatic birth where we nearly lost her and I heomaraged my milk didn't come in properly, to top it off she had severe silent reflux and would scream blue murder for every feed and just wouldn't attatch because of the feeding angle. I persevered for 5 months (but she was also on formula feeds to ensure we could get some food into her) during this time I went to a mother/baby unit and to another 4 independant lactation consultants none of whom could help however at the mere thought of me putting her onto full formula they would lay the guilt trip on so much that I would keep on trying and trying meanwhile sinking further into the ground. When I become pregnant with my 2nd child I promised myself I wouldn't go through all that anguish again if it wasn't working.
    My son was born nearly 5 months ago and this time my milk came in great guns but I think due to my previous experience my heart wasn't in it so a few times I partially weaned him and would then have a change of heart and give it another go. But then my son developed reflux and was wasn't keeping his feeds down and had also begun fussing at the breast so I made the choice to put him onto a thick anti reflux formula, however with my decision came many feelings of guilt once again. This time I breastfed for almost 4 months.
    Our stories are only 2 of many. Sometimes to put a baby onto formula is the only way that a mother is able to be the best mother she can be.

    Good luck with Leo Lisa, you are doing a fabulous job!! xoxo

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hear, hear, I say! Quite right! When you have breasts as large as mine (and they are truly exceptionally large) then bottle-feeding is your only choice. Poor Adam nearly suffocated! And as for Charly, well, it wasn't worth even trying, she was so small we may never have found her again.

    So Lisa, I say hoorah for you.

    PS Love the glasses.

    ReplyDelete
  9. WOW Lisa!!!! What a fantastic "article". My boys are well and truly grown up now (into their 30's) and whilst I didn't have mastitis I just could not produce enough milk to sustain them. The solution was easy - bottle feed or they starve!
    I admire you so much for speaking out. Only wish there had been the means, back in the 70's, to publicly make a statement like you have. One of my boys was on the verge of 'failure to thrive' because of the pressure put on me to breastfeed him. A bottle saved his life and my sanity. A baby who cries 23 out of 24 hours a day does not make for a happy family.
    All I can say Lisa, is you are a champion and I love you to bits! Well done. Granno xxx

    ReplyDelete
  10. OK, so I couldn't have kids but it doesn't stop me having an educated opinion. As soon as I heard this yesterday I was angry. It was obvious that it was going to upset all the women (like you Lisa) that tried to breastfeed and couldn't. I found the whole thing incredibly ignorant. Being a 'professional' doesn't give you the right to position something in a way that is so prejudiced (that's how it appeared to me anyway).
    Surely the information is already out there (as you said Lisa, you were bombarded with enough literature to wallpaper the babies room - ok, a little bit of poetic license on my part!).
    WOW! Didn't realise I was still angry! Thanks to David for sharing this on FB and allowing me to find Lisa's blog and show my support!

    ReplyDelete
  11. I am so with you Lisa....I am 42 years old and I 5 children and Breast fed my last 4 it was a choice i wanted to do and was determined to do even with all the pain that i went through as my nipples are inverted they bled and were cracked but i persivered...My last child is 6 months old and again was determined to do it all again after 6 weeks of so much pain and with him losing weight instead of gaining it he had comp feeds with a bottle to bring his weight back up which it did...I eventually got mastitis so after a lot of guilt feelings it came to the fact of what was best for him not me, so formula it was...he is now a very happy and fast growing little man and looking back now i know i did the best thing for him....Am glad you started this Blog well done...

    ReplyDelete
  12. Lisa you are simply the most amazing woman I have ever had the pleasure to meet. I have read your blog and I can absolutely sympethise with you. I also had trouble breastfeeding my first daughter, thank god not to the extent that you went through..., you poor darling :(. I gave up and put my daughter on the bottle at 1 week old. It was just not worth all the pain for either us, I have copped hell from people for bottle feeding my daughter and my 2 sons who followed. When my sons were born I didn't attempt to breastfeed the boys for fear of it all repeating again. It was against all the doctors advice etc, and they really make you feel like a piece of dirt. My oldest son, had hyperkaelimia so he had to have a special prescribed formula which contained no pottassium, and even then the doctors and baby health sisters gave me a serving, and he couldnt have breast milk, it would have killed him. Stand your ground sweetheart and thankyou from the bottom of my heart for standing up for of us bottle feeding mothers. I love you always sweet lovely lady xxxxxxx

    ReplyDelete
  13. i am a midwife Lisa and although our hospital is breast feeding pro (LIKE ALL HOSPITALS) just sometimes it is not right for the mother to breast feed. I also agree with what you are saying the doctor who wants formula to be on prescription only is going over the top. Mastitis is an awful thing and the complications can be terrible. whatever the choice of feeding it should be the mothers choice soley not some academic. cheers and good for you

    ReplyDelete
  14. I tried to breastfeed both of my children but my second (son) didn't "like" to be breastfed. I was starting to get him ready for when I returned to work with bottle feeds and the moment he had his first bottle...that was the end of breastfeeding. I did try for a while to express milk but it wasn't too long before my milk dried up and I had to go to formular. How dare some academic try to shame women even more...there is enough guilt put on women who have to go back to work and put their children into care with out this rubbish!! Good on you Lisa for speaking out!!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Lisa I think what you have said is wonderful. I was made to feel so guilty when I decided against breast feeding my third child. I was made to feel like it was criminal to make such a decision. I attempted feeding my first child in 1999. I feed her for 3 days before i got my first lot of mastitis and by the time my second child came in 2001 I had enduring mastitis 6 times between the 2 birhts. I didnt attempt to feed my second and was treated awfully. What followed was 3.5 years of suffereing through the most painful recurring mastitis, abcesses and Cellulitis that would never go away. I had countless amount of intreavonous Anti Biotics every 6 weeks for 3 years I had drs and nurses come to my home and stick needles into my hands arms and once they couldnt get a vein there my feet just to give me medication to stop mastitis and abcess' from poisoning me and killing me all whilst bringing up 2 beautiful young children. It put a strain on my whole family my poor husband had to work then come home and take care of 2 children my children lived in child care daily whilst i was sick because all i did was sleep. I feel like i missed the best years of their lifes. Finally in 2005 it got way too much and I ended up having a week to prepare myself for losing both my breasts. I was addmitted to hospital on the 31st august 2005 and had all of my breast tissue removed and then other tissue taken from other parts of my body too build my breasts back up. I went from size E cup to size C cup overnight. It was devastating for me and a huge amount of surgery to get over with 2 small children. Later down the track in 2007 they found i needed more surgery as the infection was again coming back.
    I was told i would never have anymore children but in 2009 my third baby was born and when i said I would not be breast feeding i was judged without even being asked my full medical history by 3 seperate midwifes. They had no idea what I had endured and even when told i was told if i didnt at least try to breastfeed I would be giving my child the worst possible start in life. I was also told that all good mothers at least try. I was devastated after many of my appointment. I came home crying to my husband that I was scared to go through the same thing again and I was not willing to go there. This third baby was a miracle after everything we had been through and i was not willing to risk missing her growing up the way i had my other 2 girls. In the end i was so stressed out by the numerous people telling me i should at least give it a go that I never hated talking to people. In the end my little girl was born 5 weeks early after i fell when out shopping with my husband and i was thankful the staff at the NICU were fantastic they did not push the issue once. They asked are you feeding or bottle feeding i stated bottle feeding and went to go into a speil as too why when they realised i was getting upset and defensive and they told me im babys mum its my decision not to let anyone make me feel guilty.

    This Dr James has really upset me. When you have a small baby who has time to race off to the drs for prescriptions everytime you run out of formula. We need to have more support out there for mothers who cannot breast feed for the many thousands of reasons. Noone should be made to feel guilty. My babys are all happy healthy and all were on formula.

    I am so sorry you have had to endure this start painful start to motherhood Lisa. I feel your pain.

    I hope you are feeling much better now and Little Leo is doing really well.

    ReplyDelete
  16. When my daughter was born (my first child)my milk didn't 'come in' after four days of trying to feed this child a sister at the hospital said to me "Mrs White you are starving this child wake up to yourself and give her a bottle" That was over 21 years ago and I am still waiting for my milk to 'come in'. I was made to feel a failure because my body couldn't feed my child and she would have all sorts of problems because I was a bad mother....I even got breastfeeding booklets in the mail from well meaning health care nurses and baby health clinic visits were a nightmare. Too this day I am still ashamed and don't talk about it much. Good on you Lisa and others for speaking out.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi Lisa, Thank you so much for your comments. I too felt so inadequate when I had to turn to the bottle to feed both of my girls. They say that breast is best and I would have if I could, but some things are just meant to be. Formula does not inhibit anything - my 15 year old daughter is currently in Italy at school, as she is in an immersion class (you need to have a few brain cells to study all your classes in another language). There is nothing wrong with my 11 year old daughter either (Laura - she is a huge DC fan by the way!)
    My Paeditrician actually said to me that bottle fed babies are more satisfied as the milk stays in the stomach for longer.
    I had immense pressure to do it - and I did. I wish I could have kept going at it, but it wasn't meant to be....
    I hope that people stop making others feel so bad at a very special time in their life.
    Thank you for speaking up - even now I feel ashamed about bottle feeding my two beautiful girls.
    The world needs more passionate people like you.
    Lynda

    ReplyDelete
  19. Lisa,

    You are a wonderful mum to Leo even if you can't breast feed him - it is not an indicator of how good a mum you are. I persevered with breast-feeding my son and I am glad I did but I am aware of women who for many reasons can not and it is a terrible place to be not because you can't but because of society's current views on the situation. Yes Breast-feeding has it's values but if you can't for what ever reason then you are the doing the right thing by bottle feeding your child as it is much better for them to receive nourishment from formula (especially today as it has almost all the nutrients as breast-milk) then to not receive nourishment at all.

    There is a lot of information out there for breastfeeding mums but hardly any for those who can't - the hospitals and medical world need to provide more and not make mum's feel bad for not breastfeeding.

    I applaud you for speaking up on this matter and as a new mum I wish you all the best for the future.

    ~*K*~

    ReplyDelete
  20. Lisa

    Congratulations on having the courage to speak out on behalf of all we mums who weren't real flash at breast feeding. Can I say that while I appreciate that breat milk might be best, a tired, frustrated and cranky mother and baby are not conducive to bonding in the early stages of this most precious relationship.

    I tried (with limited success) to feed both mine but having been a bottle fed baby I must admit I didn't have too many hangups about my lack of success in this area! (Probably the crackedd, bleeding nipples which hurt like blazes also factored into this!). I now have two happy healthy teenagers who seldom need medical attention (other than the accidental injuries), they don't have any chronic health issues, neither have learning difficulties (in fact one is just graduating from a selective high school), have healthy attitudes to life in general and generally dubunk all the myths and old wives tales surrounding bottle fed children (as do I and I grew up in the day of "Carnation Milk)!

    I only hope that this academic and all who place scorn on mothers who cannot breastfeed get their comeuppance! All power to those who conquer breastfeeding and can feed this way but by the same token we live in a society that allows us to make our own decisions about such issues so please do us the courtesy of butting out!!

    ReplyDelete
  21. I have just absolutely cried reading this.......I really, really feel for those women who want to but can't. I am a breastfeeding mother by my choice. What on Earth gives others the right to judge on how a mother feeds her baby???
    I stopped feeding my son a week before he turned 6 months old when he was diagnosed Lactose Intolerant.
    He was born 6 weeks early and arrived home after being in Neonates for 2 weeks. From the night we brought him home we had nothing but trouble. He screamed for 20/24 hours a day and would sleep for 5 minutes bursts. He was constantly in pain and there was nothing we could do. I was emotional and sleep deprived, having horrible thoughts.....and quite often behind the wheel of a car - which was a complete danger to me, my baby and everyone else on the road.
    After seeing 3 doctors who told me there was nothing wrong and that I was just being silly, we finally found our saviour (the best doctor in the world!!) who told me that if I thought there was something wrong then it had to be investigated cos a mother knows her baby. Logan was put onto the L/F formula and it was like flicking a light switch. He was an instantly changed baby from the first bottle. He slept for 2 hours while I hovered over him and cried!!! Obviously my body had had enough too cos my milk dried up over that weekend, even tho I kept expressing.
    Women don't breastfeed for many reasons, some medical some by personal choice. Why can't other people get over it?? For nearly 6 months I was putting my baby in a world of hurt and yet, I was still judged so harshly and was told I should've kept up with the breastfeeding. WHY???????? The Gastroenterologist told us that breast milk is so much higher in Lactose and that there is no additional nutritional benefit to baby being breastfed longer than 6 months anyway as by then they are normally on solids and get all there necessities from their food.
    Love and care for your child in the best way you can, no matter how that is. Give then attention and lots of hugs and cuddles and those little moments that make their childhood so special will compensate you for anything that these other unfeeling people (not just women but men also) say.
    And now to stop crying and go and wash his bottles!!!!
    Kat :)

    ReplyDelete
  22. I cried also reading all the comments as I too made the choice to bottle feed my first son 41 years ago after he was constantly being topped up when he went to the nursery after a feed - of course in those days babies were kept in a nursery and the mother only saw them at feed time - I tried expressing and sat for hours with only one inch of milk in the bottle - I at that time was not made to feel guilty by the nursing staff but I was upset for a brief period until I saw how my son thrived on the carnation milk I gave him - as did my other two children - it has only been in recent times that mothers have had more pressure on them to breastfeed only and I think it is disgraceful. Thank you Lisa for giving us mothers who know we have done our best for our babies a voice. Dianne

    ReplyDelete
  23. Good on you for talking about your experience Lisa. I wrote an article for the ABC recently on my experience with breastfeeding -
    http://www.abc.net.au/health/yourstories/stories/2010/08/12/2980681.htm

    It's amazing when you start to talk about it you realise how many others have gone through similar experiences. When you're going through it at the time you feel so alone and wonder why such a supposedly 'natural' thing has been anything but for you.

    I encourage more people to talk about their experiences with breastfeeding so that new mothers don't feel so alone and realise that having problems with feeding is natural. It doesn't work for everyone and sometimes there are very legitimate reasons for it. Only by talking about it will we start to eliminate the tremendous guilt that surrounds this topic.

    Cheers
    Renee

    ReplyDelete
  24. Well said. I breast-fed but I found it incredibly hard, especially the first time round. The (public) hospital staff were overworked and weren't encouraging at all ... in fact we new mums often found ourselves being belittled and put down if we could't feed. Every midwife/nurse had a different method. I'm not surprised so many of us gave up.
    I perservered and breast fed my first baby until he weaned himself at around 2. We enjoyed it once we got it, and it was much easier in the middle of the night or when out and about.
    My second child was born at a private hospital, and staff were much more encouraging. I had to end when she was around 1 year old because of recurrent mastitis and blood in the milk (gross I know).
    But here is my reason for commenting. As a Mum, I would NEVER EVER criticise a Mum who either has to use formula or chooses to. We are women, they are our children, it is our choice. How dare people suggest formula be prescribed only by doctors. This is insulting to women and a waste of doctors' time (unless there is a reason for a special kind of formula due to say, intolerance to something).
    Being a new Mum is wonderful and exhausting, but it is also HARD. Whichever way you do it.
    How about society shuts the hell up and just support mums, whichever way we choose to bring up our babies.
    You know what? You sound happy, your baby is obviously thriving, and that is all that matters. Good for you xo

    ReplyDelete
  25. Good on you Lisa and you shouldn't be embarassed. I couldn't feed mine either back in 1977 and my son and then my daughter were raised on Carnation Milk - obviously not full strength and they grew up to be wonderful children and adults. Sadly my son is no longer with us. My daughter has been extremely lucky in breastfeeding all 3 of hers - last one is 4 months old - but I know it wasn't all easy for her. I saw the discussion on the Today show yesterday and cannot believe what was said.
    More power to the women who feed THEIR babies the way THEY feel is right for THEM and THEIR individual situation. Thank you Lisa x

    ReplyDelete
  26. Don't you dare let those breast-feeding fascists make you feel bad. Their behavior has been thoroughly reprehensible - and for a long time. I have yet to forgive how badly they made me feel when my milk failed thirty odd years ago. I tried and tried - but, without the bottle my boys would have died.
    Those breast-obsessed women might have lots of milk - but they are seriously challenged when it comes to compassion. They are just not very nice people - smug that they were lucky in a simple organic process.
    They have earned my lifelong contempt.
    However....my bottle-fed boys are wonderful.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Every mother wants to do the very best for their child, but society & so called experts seem to think they can interfere and critisize whenever parents(particularly new mums) don't do things exactly by the book. Most new mums feel overwhelmed enough with the whole new situation, any negativity is only adding to their stress. We should only always be a source of encouragement & help. Lisa, you are to be commended for being a voice for new mums and their choices, well said! Leo thanks you too!!!

    ReplyDelete